Tesla Model X Crash - NTSB Removes Tesla from Investigation

Tesla Model X Crash - NTSB Removes Tesla from Investigation

Contrary to the NTSB's version of events, Tesla issued a statement where it said it decided itself to withdraw earlier this week as the NTSB was allegedly throttling its ability to share information before the procedure ended.

The NTSB said Tesla was removed from the investigation because releasing investigative information before it is vetted and confirmed by government regulators can produce "incomplete information" that can often lead to "speculation and incorrect assumptions about the probable cause of a crash, which does a disservice to the investigative process and the traveling public".

Initially, it was unclear whether the vehicle was in Autopilot mode, and the investigation was focused on a damaged collision barrier and the post-crash fire that complicated the emergency response.

Part of the requirements of accepting that invitation, as Tesla did in the case of this particular crash on April 6, is agreeing to abide by the NTSB's rules on public disclosure. An NTSB spokesperson said the agency was "unhappy" with the company for disclosing details during the investigation.

The stakes for Tesla's bid to defend Autopilot are significant. For a company working on the front line of autonomous driving research, those seem like very unsafe moves indeed.

The investigation was launched after Walter Huang of San Mateo was killed in March 23 while driving his Tesla Model X on U.S. Highway 101 in Mountain View. The company said the "only" explanation for the crash was "if Mr. Huang was not paying attention to the road, despite the vehicle providing multiple warnings to do so".

As a reminder here, Tesla's Autopilot system is only meant to be used by those closely watching the road, and activating the system requires an acknowledgment of this reality. The NTSB said the removal was a rare move, but Tesla's information releases "do not further transportation safety or serve the public interest".

Although Tesla won't be a formal party to the probe, the company said it will continue to provide technical assistance to the NTSB.

"The NTSB is a trusted investigatory agency". The only way the accident could have happened is if Huang "was not paying attention to the road, despite the auto providing multiple warnings to do so, "according to a statement Tesla sent April 10 to Dan Noyes, an investigative reporter with California's ABC7 News".

The family of a driver who was killed in a Tesla auto crash has hired law firm Minami Tamaki LLP to look for legal options, the law firm stated on Wednesday, adding that the Autopilot feature in the electric automaker's vehicle probably contributed to his death.

While Tesla said they are "incredibly sorry" for Sevonne's loss, they blamed the acciden ton her husband. American had taken one of the plane's two crash-proof recorders and downloaded its contents prior to turning the device over to the agency.

According to the NTSB, sharing information about an ongoing investigation with companies, emergency responders, and other groups allows those parties to take any immediate actions necessary to ensure safety. Tesla says for every 320 million miles cars equipped with Autopilot drive, there is one fatality, including known pedestrian fatalities.

That's a reference to the death of Joshua Brown, a Tesla customer who died when his Model S slammed into a truck while Autopilot was engaged.

Related:

  • New protests, clashes on Gaza-Israel border after deadly violence

    New protests, clashes on Gaza-Israel border after deadly violence

    UN Secretary-General Antonio Guterres and the European Union have called for an independent investigation into the violence. It has pledged to stop attacks, damage to the fence and infiltration bids, and says there have been attempts at all three.
    Crews investigating house fire in Greensboro

    Crews investigating house fire in Greensboro

    Investigators determined that the fire was accidental and caused by an electrical malfunction at the house's meter base. The west siding of the neighboring house was melted and damaged during the fire, but no injuries were reported.
    Santoliquito: Sydney Crosby And The Penguins Embarrass The Flyers

    Santoliquito: Sydney Crosby And The Penguins Embarrass The Flyers

    These young stars should make this series another classic one, but ultimately I think they'll fall short again in a game seven. Just like the Jets , the Bruins are insanely balanced, finishing sixth in goals forced and fourth in goals allowed.
  • Jose Mourinho wants strong Manchester United finish to secure second place

    Jose Mourinho wants strong Manchester United finish to secure second place

    However, Mourinho says the pair are part of a squad rotation system at the Theatre of Dreams and say he can't guarantee playing time to either player.
    Night owls die young in a world scheduled for early birds

    Night owls die young in a world scheduled for early birds

    The team says night owls can help themselves by trying to become exposed to light early in the morning . Knutson said that "you're not doomed".
    Chuck Schumer warns Trump not to fire Robert Mueller

    Chuck Schumer warns Trump not to fire Robert Mueller

    He's denying a report in The New York Times , and says that if he'd wanted to fire Mueller, he would have done so. Mueller should be allowed to do his job. "We'll see what happens", he said.
  • CWG 2018: Two Indian athletes suspended from Games

    CWG 2018: Two Indian athletes suspended from Games

    Divya Kakran won bronze medal in the women's freestyle 68 kg by outplaying Bangladesh's Sherin Sultana 4-0, a victory by fall. In the final, he overcame Wales' Kane Charig and notched up the required 10-point lead in a little over a minute.
    Donald Trump rages over 'lowlifes' James Comey and Andrew McCabe, Twitter erupts

    Donald Trump rages over 'lowlifes' James Comey and Andrew McCabe, Twitter erupts

    Trump responded to Comey's book for the first time Friday, calling him a "LEAKER & LIAR" and saying he "should be prosecuted". A spokesman for the inspector general's office declined to comment.

    Substitute teacher ran 'fight club' in math class, police say

    Republican leaders remained steadfast throughout the walkout that they would not hear the capital gains exemptions repeal bill. Knight is not employed by the Polk County School Board, but is employed by Kelly Educational Staffing as a substitute teacher.
  • Peerless Semenya denies Kenya gold in women's 800m

    Peerless Semenya denies Kenya gold in women's 800m

    If Team SA had taken the gold, SA would've leapfrogged Canada into fourth place on the medals table - but Mzansi had to settle for silver.
    Wall Street rises as Chinese president eases trade worries

    Wall Street rises as Chinese president eases trade worries

    The US president welcomed the speech and said he saw an end to the dispute, which has roiled markets since the start of March. And the fact that China and the United States are now locked in an escalating fight over trade likely won't help.
    BJP MLA of Unnao in rape net

    BJP MLA of Unnao in rape net

    However, as the murder charge against Atul was added later by the police, the second FIR does not reflect in the CBI's FIR. However, the CBI re-registered the FIRs lodged by the UP police and grilled the MLA (who is yet to be arrested).

Comments

Other news